In a recent online article in the Christian Science Monitor, “Racially Diverse ‘New Majority’ Set To Reshape U.S. Public Schools,” we see once again the fatal mistake made by minority parents.
The article points out that for the first time in U.S. history, non-white children will be the majority in our public schools. The frustrated parents of these children want to fix these schools to give their kids a decent education. For example, these parents complain that, as usual, their schools get less funding than ‘white’ schools, and that teachers in their schools are less experienced or competent than in the ‘white’ schools.
These parents are correct. Public schools are usually funded from local real-estate and/or income taxes. Therefore, if Black and Latino parents typically earn less than white parents and live in poorer neighborhoods, there is less funding for these schools. Also, many white teachers prefer to teach in white neighborhoods to avoid drugs and violence in minority areas. Teachers are usually given preference on where they want to teach based on seniority. Therefore, many older, more experienced teachers typically choose to teach in more ‘white’, middle-income, or higher-income “safe” neighborhoods.
These parents’ fatal mistake is that they think these government-run schools can be ‘repaired.’ They cannot. Public schools are beyond repair, and minority children will be doomed to a third-rate miserable education because the system is rigged against them. When I say the ‘system’, I don’t mean the favoritism given to schools in white areas. I mean the whole government-controlled public-school system. These schools, especially in Black and Latino neighborhoods, will never improve, precisely because they are government-run monopolies.
Public schools are “supported” and “kept in business” through compulsory school taxes, not the voluntary tuition payments of parents, as private schools are. No matter how bad these public schools are, they stay in “business,” year after miserable year, because compulsory real-estate taxes and income taxes keep them afloat. Also, no matter how bad the teachers are, it’s almost impossible to fire them, because the teachers typically get tenure after working in the system for three years.
Therefore, there is no competition that forces these schools to improve or go out of business. Because there is no competition, and because parents have no choice about how their kids are educated, these schools and teachers can arrogantly disregard parents’ anger and complaints.
In contrast, in a private school, if most parents are disgusted with the poor quality of the education and teachers in that school, they will take their children out of that school and find a better private school. The owner of the inferior private school will then go bankrupt because his customers (the parents) have voted with their feet and their consumer dollars. That is why private schools typically give a far superior education than public schools. Each private-school owner is a businessman whose very survival depends on giving his customers, the parents, quality education for their children. A private-school owner must prove to parents that his school is better than his competitors, or face going out of business and going bankrupt.
However, with government-run public schools, both parents and their children are literally prisoners of the education system. They have no choice in the school’s teachers, curriculum, or teaching methods. They have no real voice or economic power to change anything because the schools and their teachers are paid by the city or state with compulsory tax dollars, not by parents’ voluntary tuition payments. That is why these education nightmares called public schools can fail year after year for the last fifty years, and parents remain helpless to change anything.
Moreover, even when a city or state gives minority-area public schools more money, the children still get a third-rate incompetent education. Tax-funded payments per pupil in most public schools have tripled over the last 50 years, yet our children’s reading and math skills, if anything, have deteriorated. This applies to both white and non-white neighborhood schools.
That is because not only are these public schools a typically-incompetent government-run monopoly, but the teaching methods in these schools are literally guaranteed to wreck your children’s ability to read. For example, most public schools abandoned teaching children to read with phonics many years ago. Instead, they “teach” children to “read” using what’s called the “whole-language” or “balanced-literacy” method.
In this reading-instruction method, the child is asked to “memorize” words as if they were pictures, like Egyptian hieroglyphics, rather than using the phonetic sounds of the letters to sound out the word. No amount of money given to a public school will improve your child’s ability to read if public schools use this insane teaching method.
Parents, you will never get a decent education for your child in a government-controlled public school, precisely because these schools can thumb their nose at you and your anger over their incompetence. The school administrators and teachers get paid by the city or state, no matter how bad they are, and the government-enforced education monopoly has little competition.
Parents, ask yourself this question: if your local supermarket sold rotten or poisonous food, would you feed your children this food, year after year? Would you continue to shop at this supermarket, or would you immediately look for a better store where they offer quality food at a reasonable price? With all the products you buy for yourself and your children every day, such as food, clothing, toys, smartphones, cars, don’t you always choose the best for yourself and your children based on the money you can afford? Then why do you settle for a rotten education for your children from a government-controlled monopoly called public schools?
Parents, you are literally knocking your head against an education brick wall if you think these public schools will ever improve. If you love your children, I suggest you think outside the box. I suggest you walk around this brick wall. Walk away from these government education prisons that can ruin your child’s education and life.
You do not have to settle for a miserable government-school “education” for your precious children.
These alternatives include low-cost, K-12 internet private schools where the average tuition is about $1500 per year. These are real, accredited, quality private schools that can give your child a great education in the safety of your home, through the internet. In my book, “Public Schools, Public Menace,” I describe at least 23 ways you can give your child a great, low-cost education without public schools, even if you are a working parent.
Also, NEVER vote for Democratic candidates for local or national political office like Bernie Sanders or Elizabeth Warren. They all support government-run public schools and oppose school choice for parents.